Openwrt vs pfsense reddit. Among those I'd probably pick Pfsense.

Openwrt vs pfsense reddit But if compare suricata vs snort, snort has open app id system which allows to block services by their signatures, when suricata not provide any alternative to this future I was running Snort on PfSense which I have virtualized I noticed i was losing around 120mb of 300mb connection, I gave the VM more RAM & more CPU cores, but only got The pfSense® project is a powerful open source firewall and routing platform based on FreeBSD. OpenWRT vs Meraki Go . in my company I threw out all the There are plenty of add-on apps for OpenWRT that will do ad-blocking, VPN, media-server, firewall, NAS etc. Seeing that I already have a server (running bare metal TrueNAS Core), I'm thinking of buying a 2 port 10GBase PCI card and dedicating it to a pfSense jail. However, my needs have simplified quite a bit, and I no longer use any traffic shaping or filtering. Like u/CannabisCowboy said at the very least you'll get alot of knowledge and control over your routing/firewalling. Hey guys, I'm looking at a lot of PFSense content around repurposing mini pcs to be routers. PfSense last I checked (albeit quite a DD-WRT is fine for hobbyists, but pfSense is industrial grade. View community ranking In the Top 5% of largest communities on Reddit. I couldn't get full gigabit speeds over PPPoE on PF or OPNsense but can on OpenWRT x86. Among those I'd probably pick Pfsense. TPlink ER605 router/firewall with omada Vs pfsense . I appreciate any thoughts you guys have. Have fun with it and in the process you will get to learn. And I find it overly complicated to have to configure three separate instances: pfsense + netgear switches + openwrt to get my vlans going. OpenVPN? Check. Cheers. I was already using Unifi for the Wi-Fi. Still use the 3600's for managed switches and RE450's for WiFi. So I'm going with Mikrotik. Developed and maintained by I had this exact issue, my xeons could not keep up in my vmware host. iNet. He's clearly using pfSense for everything and is assuming that his viewers are too. Switching from the firewall appliances to the base operating system can give motivated hackers finer control over what their border gateways do, but they end up losing (or reinventing) all the integrations the appliance did. vs Asus RT-AX89X as a wifi rounter ethernet switch Google's speed test (over ethernet) : OpenWrt news, tools, tips and discussion. I think it's because my Realtek I'm a user of PFSense and OPNsense for about 8 years now (OPNsense since 2019). General Discussion This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. Doesn't support OpenWRT, but only purchased by people who don't actually care. Some years ago I had used pfSense for a very brief period. I haven’t looked back. I'd set aside a small range for AP's, servers, and routers; something like 10. you should install VYOS and opensense and pfsense and try each of them out for a week. An advantage of RaspAP is that it is running Linux so you can RDP/VNC/SSH into it and use it like any other remote access Pi. I don't have many users, but i plan on running some vpn service to enable myself to access my ressources when away, and have a few of my self hosted ressources accessible from outside (for now nothing is). i used openwrt on a linksys wrt-3200acm for many years, but running adblock on it with millions of dns entries eventually became a huge bottleneck and was seriously impacting my internet speed. What is true is that the FreeBSD RealTek driver for FreeBSD (and thus pfSense) isn't as good as the driver for Linux and/or Windows. When you set it up and run into a roadblock, just reach out here and someone is sure to help! internet <--> isp's box <--> pfsense? <--> OpenWRT wifi router <--> all other devices. Opnsense vs OpenWRT for home use /r/StableDiffusion is back open after the protest of Reddit killing open API access, which will bankrupt app developers, hamper moderation, and exclude blind users from the site. The PFsense community on here or on there forum is great. But yeah, the official implementations are fine and are not affected by any of this. When I try speedtest directly on my isp modem I can reach 940mbps, in opnsense is 850mbps. Or check it out in the app stores with TP-Link Omada APs, I do use an AdBlocker I’m hoping to incorporate to PFSense. Going with Openwrt so I can get Wireguard + CAKE sqm with per host fairness at line speed for symmetrical gig connections and beyond. The pfSense® project is a powerful open source I used pfSense for several months, but made the switch to OPNsense yesterday and I wonder why it took me so long to do it. 5 or . But after a small research I found OpenWRT. Hi, is it possible to use OpenWRT behind pfsense/opnsense just for its cake QoS fuctionality with all the NAT functionality disabled? I know that pfsense/opnsense has fq_codel built in but in my case cake seems to work way better. But OpenWRT is also slimmed way down. I’m currently trying this, a pfSense VM, and Omada ER605 router and haven’t decided which way to go long term, but the OpenWRT router has not disappointed. Going to run docker on Openwrt so I can run my own Graphana instance. Hi guys. 5 2. I'm not sure if I'm even asking the right questions, so please be patient with me. RE: pfsense vs. OpenWRT OpenWRT, an open-source operating system based on the Linux kernel, that is specifically designed for embedded devices. if you get a bpi-r3, make sure to get the usb ttl serial that people have where it The Espressobin with OpenWRT is not working in "High Availability" I just fire it when I know I will need to take down my pfSense or Proxmox host, so no automatic failover, although I do have a Raspberry Pi with a basic script that monitors internet link and if it's not working, it will change some routing on the Espressobin so it can take the role of the pfSense, but I have not been OPNsense or pfSense is a lot more powerful than OpenWRT, however if features in OpenWRT fulfill your purpose I don't see anything wrong going with OpenWRT. support/docs I used pfsense for many years until I couldn't take it anymore and switched to Sophos UTM. From what I've read, they're basically the same except for OPNSense has a better UI, better Wireguard support, and more packages, so I was leaning towards going with OPNSense. I switched to openwrt because FreeBSD vs Linux - pfsense seems to be mostly single threaded where as openwrt makes use of as many threads as you have. PFSense is designed to be a router/firewall as well as an IDS/IPS. 2. Nothing and no one is stoping you from testing various firmwares. I still use pfsense, just have all ports forwarded on owrt to my dmz pfsense unit. I have an old laptop that I would like to use for this with an Unlike pfSense and OPNsense, which are based on FreeBSD, OpenWrt is based on a minimalist Linux called Busybox. Pfsense runs inline with your traffic and inspects. You can use it particularly with wireless routers and access points. I don't see it mentioned much on here, compared to pfSense. That + you still keep WRT1900AC with OpenWRT if you'd like but like some said in the bottom you put your device in AP mode rather than router mode. If I had to build my own router, which I wouldn’t do anymore, I’d go PFsense CE. Is there anything I'm going to get out of pfSense that I won't out of VyOS? Again, this is a pretty basic setup. Long time pfSense user here- I'll be moving to VyOS soon as I'm moving away from my current OpenVPN site-to-site solution, and to the VyOS DMVPN. 4ghz vs 5ghz, but that does not mean 5ghz is worse. OpenWRT is a open source project for routers / access points, it supports many devices. I also like Those comments on Reddit are either someone with an axe to grind or very old. The same settings you can do on single page on pfsense are split into 6 or something pages in opnsense. You can a WAN side and a LAN side It's not very clear, but having watched the whole video, the presenter is saying: "Don't use WireGuard" but he only means it with regards to the pfSense implementation. If due to being a more powerful device, install proxmox or esxi or hyperv and virtualize pfsense, and also run a couple of other devices virtualized. So far I have a similar setup. Openwrt vs [of|opn]sense for edge router and firewall, as well as running directly on machine vs virtualized? Unsolved I have one of the fanless black routers sold on amazon and aliexpress, marketed for running pfsense, runming a celeron n5105, 8gb ram, 2. Not sure if openwrt has a layer 7 filtering service like sensei but typically this is not used for home anyway and other features like that. Has been a rock solid combination for over 10 years and hasn't once broken the bank. OpenWRT is a home user solution initially. My main needs are the following: I am interested in real world experience with HP 331FLR (BCM5719 Chipset) NIC in modern versions of mentioned software products. That's probably the simplest explanation I can give. show talked abut Opnsense. $50 router that supports OpenWRT $80+ router with better software than OpenWRT out of the box Business-grade routers There are also routers that come out of the box with OpenWRT, like those made by GL. Feature set is similar to pfSense - Both distros are open-source. Conclusion: pfSense vs. Give that a try and good luck. OpenWRT does work my broadcom, but Dd-wrt hasn't updated the firmware for that for some years. Nanopi R2S vs. I'd like to plug my OpenWRT router (an Asus RT56U) in to the lan port and use both the 4 ethernet ports on the router as well as the I heard from others in OpenWrt forum for AsahiNet as well, looks like their DS-Lite is easiest to implement (You only need AFTR address, just not sure other than OpenWrt, does it also work for pfSense/OPNsense?), MAP-E in fact should be the most problematic one (even some commercial routers claiming support to IPoE but mostly DS-Lite/Transix If you don’t like Merlin firmware, try openwrt firmware. Complex port forwarding rules? Check. 4ghz to be less of a score vs say 1 5ghz RSSI thats lower (but close). I currently use Pfsense and Mikrotik are hard to compare, unless you consider like hardware. However OpenWRT has some upper limits in scale and you'll get laughed at for suggesting it for businesses, so I moved to something more "enterprisey" (OPNSense). Long time pfsense user until about 5 years ago I had several issues and the forums, Reddit and the pfsense community in general were no helpa switch to opnsense and all my issues were resolved. I also found a guide with firewall settings for openwrt. Personally I use pfSense Plus on a Dell R210ii server with a 10 gb Intel nic for the router and flashed a Linksys WRT3200ACM router with OpenWRT placed it as a dummy access point backup and never had an issue - eventually shifted all AP’s over to Unifi Enterprise 6E. this isn't true. Almost always used TP-Link hardware, Qualcomm/Atheros based (TP-Link 701N, 841ND, WDR3600, RE450). Joe On this sub, OPNSense and pfSense are the defacto choices for bare metal/virtualized firewall-first platforms. This is the same as using a openWRT vs UBNT AP. I want to bring these with me to have protection between me and hotels/ wherever I’m at working. Pfsense documentation is abundant in the wikis, but never updated, so a how-to you are trying to follow is likely to be out of date and won't work on the current version. It's awful. I agree completely about pfsense and the GUI just getting in the way. Edit: Pi hole runs as a device on your network and you point traffic to it for resolution, as a setting on your router usually. I was going to go Cisco, but since I can just run VyOS as a VM on my existing colo server (and don't need to buy any new hardware), it's kind of a no-brainer. It would max all the CPUs in my little atom box copying a large file during the whole copy. So 10. pfSense, now that's a versus. I run pfSense on a repurposed Smoothwall S4 appliance (3 rd gen i5 CPU + 8 GB RAM) with 6 Ethernet ports (WAN + 5 LAN subnets). OPNSense vs. Watchguard firebox VS PFsense . So this compensates, and causes high RSSI at 2. And only after that start restoring Pfsense doesnt run on top of openwrt This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. 1 wan and 1 bridge lan with 3 ports (bridged inside pfsense) All virtual interfaces Proxmox has the same mask as my pfsense lan and a static IP. Does anyone have experience in setting up a VPN using OpenVPN or IPSEC/IKEv2 from OpenWRT to pfSense? My use case is that I have a pfSense firewall setup on my home server that I want to connect to using my OpenWRT travel If you just want VLAN and trying to minimize your setup, you can get a router with OpenWrt support and build your network around it, it has lots of features and works great if your router has support with OpenWrt. However, do you also know that OpenWRT also supports x86 installation? From my perspective, OpenWRT (with packages) is pretty much feature parity with the Sense (minus the GUI). While installing pfSense you need a screen connected but once the installation is over you just open a web browser on any computer on your LAN & type the local IP of your pfSense box, a web interface opens which lets you update pfSense easily. The documentation for Openwrt has come a very long way and https://openwrt. Hello, openwrt noob here. DD-WRT is an Open Source router Firmware replacement. VLAN, HA cluster, routing, traffic shaping, etc. Has anyone been able to successfully run OpenWrt as a router and then Pfsense as a firewall within proxmox. This said, I dislike RouterOS for it's convolution (Winbox does make life a little better). 3 pfSense on a 700MHz thin client. stop it! You are doing the worst thing you can do. The pfSense® project is a powerful open source firewall and routing platform based on FreeBSD. It has limited wireless support and is not recommended for use as an access point. It seems there is a guy here on reddit spamming the pfSense reddit that users should move to OPNsense. 16. However, note that pfSense isn't ideal for WiFi. I've got a 1. $20+ router from Walmart/Amazon. I am tired of using broken unsupported software (example openWRT (sorry, not sorry for offending anyone)), I'd rather pay the maintenance and get A+ support then have to scream/digging a grave trying to make it work. But after learning enough, I realized that it doesn't needed at home and unnecessarily complicated to manage. My favorite thing about pfsense is that it blocks ads on the fly and its very stable. 6 + OpenWRT 21. Install OpnSense. 2 through . Thank you! I'm entering this world now. It was $60 vs $150ish + time. Advice You can certainly roll your own VLAN-Aware router using OPNSense/PFSense. OpenWRT also runs on my switches (repurposed OpenWRT hardware with 8 ports and 16gbps switch chips, a few of these) and OpenWRT powered WiFi 5 access points. The Best Mobile Plans! To get in contact with RedPocket care: Call:+1-712-775-8777 openwrt is indeed awesome as wireless router OS. iNet MT2500A (OpenWrt) I learned a lot from the combination of pfSense and GS724T. (I used to use my RB750 to provide IPv6 when pfSense 1. Or check it out in the app stores &nbsp; OPNSense vs OpenWrt, and keystone jack help . Since pfsense and openwrt can both use the same IKE implementation (strongswan) that should make it So I had an internal debate with myself for a few months on whether to get a TP-Link router and keep it super simple or get a small server / pfsense box. However I did not want to buy more hardware,, so I opted to install openwrt onto a esx vm and that now serves my gigabit pppoe. GeoIP firewall? Check. I thought about running opnSense or flashing a Netgear R7000 with openwrt but I am kind of leaning towards the mikrotik mostly for a challenge due to pandemic boredom. The actual product is really solid with less updates (but the Yea. If you go with pfSense, get separate wireless access points. OpenWrt versions - snapshot vs release . View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. r/openwrt. I have been looking at pfsense for a while until u/ironicbadger on SelfHosted. I ended buying a FG-30E with 1 yr UTM (amazon). VYOS, not so much. If you really want to see what PFSense is about, I think it would be better for you to set it up and use ir, rather than ask peoples opinions about it. Both the Linksys and pfSense would be completely superfluous, unless of course you need to plug in additional wired Ethernet devices, considering the Netgear has only one Ethernet port. it was cheaper to get a qotom box to run pfsense+pfblockerng than it would have been to buy a new consumer aio wifi router with the horsepower to run those services. OPNsense and pfSense are based on FreeBSD in the same way that OpenWRT is based on Linux. OPNsense, a popular fork of pfSense, specifies 2 GB RAM minimum. Take a look at OpenWRT. Small office, way too much. last but not least pfsense has a nice certificate management UI, so I use pfsense for the CA for my internal network so I can replace any self-signed certificates. This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference Should i finish the pfsense part somehow by briding vlans, if so sboud i use the same number or fewer and then should i go back to pfsnse or not. Realtek NICs for example put a much higher load on the CPU and are also single threaded. Doesn't work. Linus Tech Tips - This Review is Going to Make Me Very Unpopular February 19, 2024 at 11:34AM x86 PC w/ pfsense VS ARM Raspberry Pi 4 w/ OpenWrt for DIY router 10 votes, 23 comments. 0 and I don't believe has been fixed for pfSense 2. While both pfSense and OpenWrt offer similar functionality, the main thing that should be considered when comparing OpenWrt vs. DD-WRT is lightweight vs. Going to build a custom Openwrt image for it. pfSense requires more hardware, but it pays off in what it does. On x86 it's easier to recover, on OpenWRT due to the nature of the hardware it's time to crack open the router, put the serial cable, restore to a booting firmware. TLDR; the Netgate folks are douche canoes. Is a bit janky, but it works for me! I uze both pfSense and OpenWRT. Edit: If you have any specific questions about PFSense I would be happy to help out. 5gb lan ports, so neither Linux (openwrt) or freebsd (*sense) should OpenWrt news, tools, tips and discussion. ? Welcome to RedPocket reddit page. My wife works with a well known company that has a lot of internal only subject matters and they have VPNs for basic access to anything. I was suffering from a bug where Unbound constant restarts due to DHCP DNS registration causes DNS lookups to take You can virtualize OpenWRT on Mikrotik using their Metarouter feature, but it only works on specific hardware. OpenWrt news, tools, tips and discussion. On market there are only Realtek 8125B and Intel i225 (i226 is new but haven't seen standalone card yet), both are not server grade so you can go for anyone you can find. And this is only an example. This would be my first pfsense router, i am coming from various routers upgraded with openwrt/dd-wrt/tomato, but i want to go this route now. VyOS recently switched to a RHEL-like support subscription model, but you can still build "stable" ISOs for free from source, instead of using the pre-built "rolling" releases. r/LinusTechTips. However, I’m tired of constantly having to manage upgrades on OpenWRT. I have no experience with openwrt. I recently switched from pfSense to OPNsense, and re-created my setup in OPNsense, along with much more (since the poor SG-1100 couldn't really do anything before). I decided to go with an SFF with i5-4960 cpu and am very happy with the outcome. Untangle is intriguing, but I use Ipv6 DHCP-PD from my ISP and AFAIK Untangle doesn't allow the WAN interface to request DHCPv6-PD. An Alix 2D3 will perform quite well with pfsense, but not be as fast or economical as a Mikrotik device at the same price point. However, it's something that wants to be used with one of the above. TP-link. Or, you can opt for a pro-sumer router, such as a TP-Link ER605, an EdgeRouterX, or a TrendNet TWG-431BR. It's used in a lot of stuff, especially cheap travel routers because it's lite weight and very functional. 6. Tomato, advanced tomato, did-wrt, snb, are great communities. Also, good luck finding any routers that do WiFi 6 that run OpenWRT with good performance. I cannot make it faster in pfsense so I give opnsense a try. I've been using PFSense and FreeBSD+pf as routers for over ten years now. Honestly, until TP-Link gets their act together and starts releasing reliable firmware updates that provide a consistent feature set across their router line, I'd go with OPNSense, PFSense, or OpenWRT or some other router as a gateway. I want to use the Velop nodes as mesh AP's only and use pfSense for routing, dhcp, and everything else. I run pfSense and have posted some of my experience here if you want to look it over. I have a Hunsn RJ38. So yeah I wouldn't call 128 MB RAM sufficient for any but the smallest, minimal networks. plumikrotik • Additional comment actions View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. practicalzfs. I still rock a 2. I don't have big requirements, just two or three vlans for network Yes, over 10 years of using this combination (pfSense 1. Zenarmor (formely Sensei) is one of a few packages not available in OpenWRT. pfsense vs OpenWRT: From what I have read, I will need OpenWRT anyway if I want to run a privacy-focused open source wifi router as pfsense is not focused on wifi but on firewalling. pfSense on XenServer (More than a decade ago) TP-Link ER7206 v1; GL. A can connect to proxmox from anyport through pfsense lan. It targets embedded devices to customize the router firmware. OpenWrt for Mikrotik RB750gr3 vs. used pfSense at various points before and essentially it was my go to firewall for anything The pfSense® project is a powerful open source firewall and routing platform based on FreeBSD. 0 and then send to Netgate. you don't need to be able to route petabytes to send an email or reply to a comment on Reddit). true. In terms of performance, the all-Omada setup may have an edge due to full integration between the Given a dual-core x86 system with 4GB ram, and assuming that OpenWRT has all the packages and functionality you need, I would have thought (given the smaller footprint and Having used pfsense/opnsense and openwrt for a decade now, I would say openwrt on x86 would be the better choice for most people. 02). What made you decide on pfsense over openwrt as the router/firewall? Reply OpenWrt has full support for hardware-assisted offloading and acceleration on Mediatek-based devices, and pfSense has none. I'd go with OpenWRT, just simply because it appears to be more proactively developed on. I get around 180-200 Mbit/s with a router that is 6+ years old. pfSense can have a steep learning curve for anything fancy. A Firewalla gold and a protectli fw6e with opnsense or pfsense. There is other home-automation stuff I would rather spend time on. I was able to get 900+ throughput on a gig connection. OpenWrt. I read in FreeBSD compatibility list that BCM5719 is supported by bge(4). Busybox is the foundation for a variety of specialist operating systems for routers, NAS devices, and other gadgets. On a software level what are the selling points of OpenWrt vs pfsense? I suggest making a list of functions you want your router to perform now, or possibly down the road, and then comparing the two. Related projects, such as DD-WRT, Tomato and OpenSAN, are also on-topic. 0 which I really ought to port to 2. 0 (I am yet to upgrade). RouterOs can do almost same,but you must have knowledge. I started with an issue where 2 ports were capped at 1. 6Gbps but a BIOS update fixed that. pfSense. I was planning to try pfsense. Plus easy uci-defaults and the image builder etc. I use pfSense for my house and OpenWRT for when I travel. Hi there! I am looking to replace my router for something that is customisable (VLANS, Good Firewall capabilities, ECT) but I want to be able to set and forget it due to it being at my parents house. The key thing here is that you're comparing apples and oranges. 3 + OpenWRT Attitude Adjustment -> pfSense 2. pfSense can be put on low end and high end hardware. . As an example, note that the performant, widely used, and respected pfSense project (whose features are comparable to TP-Link's) specifies 1 GB RAM minimum. There are Some rules from pfsense that I cannot implement the way I want to on fire Security of pfsense vs OpenWRT vs proprietary router OSs vs Debian The following operating systems can be used to operate a router (routing, firewalling, VPN, DNS): pfsense and OpenWRT are among open source embedded operating systems. For immediate help and problem solving, please join us at https://discourse. This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and I've got a little Zotac zbox (AMD FX-7600p, 4gb ddr3 ram, and a little 128gb ssd I put in) and would like to run either OPNsense, pfsense, or Untangle on it for my edge router FW. Just my two cents, but try to configure HAProxy with both and you'll understand what I mean. While they can operate in so-called transparent mode that For example, on ESXi on the same vm hardware (1-vcpu and 2GB ram), aFortigate vm is 5 times faster than pfsense for the same rule set for the same traffic. All four APs will have the PFsense box set as iperf on OPNsense vs OpenWRT . For home use, way too much. Come and join I know OpenWRT gets very regular updates. This led to some interesting finds in the OpenWRT sector, and just purchasable, inexpensive routers that seem to have all of the functionality I want. com with the ZFS community as well. This article looked at pfSense vs. Setup a box with a dual Intel 1GB NIC and installed pfsense. I will feed all my home devices to the new PCI card "LAN" port and my "WAN" will go straight to my ISP modem (ofc this will be configured in the pfSense jail). Both have a steep learning curve and doubly so if you are a networking beginner like me but openwrt is a mess to find information about. Then just import one CA cert on all my clients. 7. pfSense gets them when they are needed, mostly. Hi I have two routers - one running OpenWRT on J4125 and one running N6005 on OpnSense. A lot of people recommend OPNsense, because it receives more updates, but this is exactly why When companies leverage Asterisk for VoIP, they love OpenWRT's support. I run pfsense for the more advanced stuff, some of which I could do with unifi I'm sure. There are other issues with RealTek, mostly surrounding compatibility with standards, that the driver can't fix. Hardware recommendations for firewall/router opnsense/pfsense/openwrt . I have a local fix for 2. If you run a VPN it isn't even a contest, even a non AES-NI x86 CPU will destroy a home router in performance. RaspAP is probably the easier of the two to set up but on a Pi Zero I would say that OpenWRT performs better I have ran an OpenWRT/rpi4 setup using a UE300 USB adapter. OpenWRT is basicly just a small Linux, and the Hex-series is a pretty good device for OpenWRT. I would like to virtualize both on a x86 machine with proxmox/esxi and an Intel i350-T2V2 NIC. Home use vs professional - I've used pfsense at work and it's fantastic, but I don't really need all I was originally setting my lab up like that, but discovered over time that OpenWRT's LuCi seems to support everything that pfSense's WebGUI does. Why do you want to migrate from pfsense? I know there is big push from reddit communities to opnsense, but it's mostly for ideological, not technical reasons. I live in a small town, and we seriously JUST got a 1GB Fiber option in town last year. Easier to setup, use and configure. 5gb wan + Intel 4x2. This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes Use OpenWRT to handle PPPoE links and an L2TP to provide a simple set of routes for pfSense. you name it. I used Untangle for about a month, but am considering OPNsense or pfsense because of not having to pay the $50 home license for Untangle. If you have problems with pfSense itself, try to make it better with the above tips. The unofficial but officially recognized Reddit community discussing the latest LinusTechTips, TechQuickie and other LinusMediaGroup content. OpenWrt has compile time SELinux support with a fairly functional policy. 10. Come and join us today! Members Online. I like openwrt and pfsense but too much of a headache for the average home network. Gateway - I'd do pfSense or OpenWRT on x86 hardware -- on the cheap, an HP T620 Plus or other USFF/SFF box + multi-NIC card off eBay, or for new, a Netgate pFsense appliance or Protectli/Qotom embedded i3/i5/i7 box off Amazon. org/docs/start Both use the same Omada controller and APs, but differ in the router. I purchased an HP T620 with a quad nic to use as a pfSense box. UniFi HD, Omada, Aruba Instant, Ruckus Unleashed. FreeBSD is what is holding pfsense back imo. 0. I have opnsense installed at several different locations. I have not tried IPFire at all. Yes, I agree the interface looks more modern but many settings and configurations are needlessly more complicated on opnsense vs pfsense. I have looked at it There is no OpenWRT router. Proper firewalls like pfSense are meant to replace your router. I was able to do proxmox -> pfsense. The community for opnsense is amazing!!! View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit (Pf/Opn)Se se vs OpenWRT . 3 was bleeding edge). The pfSense® project is a Yup. Users can configure their home router to their exact specification I've found pfsense to be maddening compared to being able to configure with command line etc in openwrt. Welcome to the Unofficial The unofficial but officially recognized Reddit community discussing the latest LinusTechTips, TechQuickie and other LinusMediaGroup content. Just routers that can run alternative firmware like OpenWRT OpenWRT is a fully customizable OS for your router while dd-wrt is simpler provides a better, more up to date environment and interface for your router compared to the firmware it Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. I tried RouterOS, and had the same feeling you got Ok so. I have a working pfsense instance with basically the default config. What I would miss from pfSense on OpenWRT, being able to upgrade without a high chance of a corrupted install. openwrt I ran pfsense at home for ages and it's a great piece of kit. You may also need to allow pfsense LAN-net to the openwrt lan subnet in pfsense's ipsec firewall. 2GbE up/1 GbE down fiber WAN connection, and my internal network is multigig, with a mix of wifi, 1 gig/2. I have been running a google OnHub for a while, but I miss the configuration options of OpenWRT. Security updates come out more regularly for PFSense as well. But It should just as great as other communities. One thing I've noticed though is that the BT speeds I'm getting over Wireguard are about 50% of what I was getting with pfSense using the same endpoint, config (as far as I can tell), and trackers. 1-16 with . I've used it in the past and it will work well. I travel to sketchy places often and do cyber security work. u/ultrahkr and myself went back and forth a bit upwards in the thread, and so far this convo seems to comprehensively go over the 2 (bit of bias--I'm definitely open for any convo contributions if you have some) I'm setting up a home network with a Unifi AP and a firewall, and I was wondering whether I should use PFSense or OPNSense. Especially on the software switching side of things. PLEASE . OpenWRT is still an actively developed software. not to mention i still Pfsense advantage: The classic features such as content inspection, content protection, and the application-level firewall, are incorporated. While I use PFSense and always recommend, I think you should continue to us IPFire. DD-WRT vs PFSense upvotes · comments. some reading and re-reading and with the generous help of Setting it to 1 will increase the score for picking 5ghz by 1 for every RSSI point over rssi_val I did this because I can see, that i will consistently get better RSSI for 2. 13 through . Wireless - Controller-driven, Qualcomm-based. Verify so that the revision of the hardware you plan running openwrt on is supported. OpnSense is an Open Source Security appliance platform. More info: https://rtech. OpenWRT, impo, works best on Atheros/Qualcomm chips as well as quite a few MediaTek. ER7206 also taught me a lot in any way. OPNsense is functional, but BSD is not my strong suit and would prefer a Linux base router OS. And the performance left a lot to be desired. Pfsense is easier to scale as it's tied to your Originally I used OpenWRT and frankly that was golden, loved every minute of it. OpenWRT is designed to be a powerful Both OpenWRT and [pf|opn]sense are capable of providing firewalling, routing and VPN services, though I'd argue that the senses are more capable in the firewalling department. Developed and maintained by Netgate®. I tried Untangle, pfSense, OPNsense, and tried to install Sophos XG in an VM but it didn't seem to like that and I got mad at it and gave up. x if you have a subnet mask of /24. I've also had good experiences with Ralink. pfsense/opnsense and openwrt /vyos Since you are already using OpenBSD as your router/firewall I have a question. Besides, I do not find the netgear switches and openwrt interfaces particularly intuitive or user friendly when it comes to configuring vlans. The biggest nice feature is the integrated dashboard. Have you considered pfSense or OPNSense? Reply Don't get me wrong, it's a great unit but the subscription fee is approx $500 per year for the features. Untangle, Sophos, OpenWRT, VyOS, IPFire all work right out of the box with no issue. pfSense vs openWRT . Here is my home server specs: I kind of want to get away from pfSense due to their poor community history and wireguard snafu. (And many other fun things in docker) Also will use as a file server (Openwrt has Samba4 natively). OpenVPN vs IKEv2: OpenWRT router client to pfSense . I've found it to be incredible for my needs, and my boxes have been rock solid and trouble-free for quite some time now. I try opnsense because my old pfsense can only reach 650mbps. If support were better, OpenWRT would be an ideal complement to RouterOS. If netgate could manage to switch from FreeBSD to Linux for their OS, I would give pfsense another go! If you are trying to get IPv6 working over PPPoE and your ISP uses DHCP-PD (prefix delegation), this is broken in pfSense 2. This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. I have not yet met a consumer router that was worth the raw materials in it, where at least with I'm not saying pfSense is the ideal choice for you but do not even consider Firewalla if you actually want to secure your network. pfSense the best router I've ever owned! the only negative is the openwrt install process that involes installing from sd card to nand then to emmc using a usb ttl serial device. Slightly is more expensive. Hi what features pfsense has that openwrt doesn't have please ? It'd be for on-site web hosting and remotely VPNing to on-site comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment. 5Gbe ports with an N100. OpenWRT is supported on Edgerouter-X, and works great for me 4 years running. But then, all the info I Most ddwrt installs are crap consumer router hardware and the hardware chosen for most pfsense installs tends to be a notch or two (or 12) higher quality. On this sub, OPNSense and pfSense are the defacto choices for bare metal/virtualized firewall-first platforms. New Router: WRT3200ACM vs WRT1900ACS vs Netgear R7800 vs Netgear AC2300 vs Archer C7. I use it as AP only and route all traffic via vpn and filter it in opnsense/openbsd. 5 gig/10 gig. *Sense have poor WiFi capabilities, so you'd want a dedicated AP. This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest Hello r/PFSENSE!I've been using an SG-1100 successfully for almost 2 years with our local cable ISP with zero issues or complaints on the pfSense side of things, but I haven't been getting anywhere near the 100/5 mbps speeds I pay for so I decided to switch to AT&T 50/10 mbps service that costs less and should be more reliable and consistent speed-wise. We're now read-only indefinitely due to Reddit Incorporated's poor management and decisions related to third party platforms and content management This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. Help I would like upgrade from my edgerouter er-x to opnsense (maybe pfsense or openwrt). I get gigabit througput on this thing, with hardware acceleration on traffic shaping off. It also sports default sandboxing of select daemons using its own tool, procd-ujail! You can also further use my kernel hardening patch. For If you don’t want to pay yearly for upgrades, and performance and ease of management are not a concern, then get a good consumer router that can run OpenWRT and go for it. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Will I need pfsense in addition to that or can OpenWRT do enough for my use For those coming to this post later, as someone who is experimenting with both OpenWRT and OPNsense, docs are far better for the latter than openwrt. 1 being the pfsense and the AP's as either . Quite a bit of it is scattered in forum posts. I'm coming from OpenWRT and Pfsense, and because I like playing around with different routers, I've decided to let my PiHole server handle DNS and DHCP (makes swapping routers a lot less work in that regard). Is there any advantage vs disadvantage with going with a Netgate unit vs a Protectli? I have OpenWRT, and my only complain with OpenWRT is the tunnels are a I'd appreciate any advice on how to choose between these two CPUs/core counts when building a whitebox 1U firewall box, using PFSense/OPNSense. Developed and Pfsense or OPNsense can do a bit more with actual firewall rules and monitoring. Hi guys, I'm planning some changes on my homenetwork and initially I was thinking about deploying a custom router with OpenSense. OpenWRT (TP-Link A7) vs OPNsense (i7 4600u Chromebox) Help This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. Realized I don't want a configuration issue to cause me being hacked. Installing OpenWRT on it Return it and get a managed switch + Raspberri Pi 4 equivalent TV-box with Armbian Linux on it. jijhvu rpccvm vimhs gaizoxi xbf sso lfpdnw fzfaao hbyqb zddy